Can a Tablet Replace a Laptop for Good?

Illustration: Gordon McAlpin

With the announcement and impending release of the iPad 3, it’s important to point out that as advanced as tablets are, there are still things they can’t do that a laptop can do.

1. Microsoft Office
Though there are strong rumors of an upcoming Microsoft Office app for the iPad, to date there is no way to effectively handle Word or Excel documents on a tablet. Sure, you can often transfer over and edit such documents using specialized apps, but at best, you’ll only be able to control rudimentary creation and editing functions. A feature like Tracked Changes would be invisible to a “compatible” tablet app, and it’s anyone’s guess which version you’d see on an app with changes tracked: the original, or the revision? These kinds of uncertainties make professional Office-format creation on a tablet impossible to date.

2. PC Compatibility
From running specific applications to specific web browsers to specific games, tablets aren’t PCs. Even the odd Windows tablet is not going to be exactly the same as PC’s Windows (Windows 8 tablets and PCs will be extremely close … but who’s honestly going to own a Windows 8 tablet over an Android or Apple one?) There will always be applications that don’t exist on tablets, or are approximations that aren’t close enough.

3. Flash
Sure, some Android tablets support Adobe Flash, but implementation is terrible, and the recent Ice Cream Sandwich operating system update seems to have broken Flash compatibility. Also, Adobe is ending support for mobile Flash, and even the ultra modern new iPad has zero Flash support. Until Web standards have moved away from Flash completely, there will always be websites that will be unusable on a tablet.

4. Extra Batteries
Most tablets do not have removable batteries. Power laptop users often carry multiple batteries with them for long trips away from a power outlet (and have Battery Optimizer installed, naturally). Tablet users don’t have that luxury. Once you get through the 10 hours or less of battery life on the typical tablet, that’s it.

5. USB Devices
USB support is all but nonexistent on tablets, limited to charging or PC sync on some models. Say you’d like to plug in an external hard drive or thumbdrive for more space, a game controller, a mouse or a wireless device that’s not Bluetooth. You’re out of luck. Speaking of Bluetooth, though, many Bluetooth variations on the above do work with tablets. Good luck finding a Bluetooth hard drive, though.

6. Mass Storage
SD Card support on tablets is nonexistent on the iPad, not implemented on the Xoom and spotty otherwise. You’re trapped with the amount of storage on the device. Android and others encourage you to store your files on the cloud, but if you’d like a physical backup of those files, you’re going to have a hard time.

7. Wired Internet
Sometimes Wi-Fi or 3G/4G isn’t enough, especially if the signal is terrible. Sometimes your office only has a hardline, and you don’t feel like (or can’t) add a Wi-Fi router. Your tablet won’t be able to connect, which can cost you.

All these things add up to the fact that tablets are awesome for many functions, but don’t completely take the place of a laptop. It’s getting closer all the time, and it may be that someday you won’t need (or miss) some of the above. We’ll see what happens!

  • glenbdcs

    Steve, please please look at what you have written, you cannot stop the next beach tide!
    Who said we should have Microsoft Office -it’s huge, it cost’s a lot and most of us only ever use 10%. We use it now because that’s all there has been for too long.
    Anyone who is using a tablet over 10 hours is going to be exhausted.
    I have watched my wife thoroughly enjoy using her tablet whilst also watching TV (remember they are supposed to be better at multi-tasking than us males) and now I simply ask her to look up something that has caught my interest and moments later she has Google answers. We never did that with a PC or a heavy laptop. Roll on the TV audio synchronising with search engines to explore even further watch we watch.

    There is always going the a place for multiple devices (PC. Laptops, Tablets, Smart phones) and I will continue to use my PC and Laptop when I need more screen/s or power at work or at clients but then when I don’t need it e.g waiting to board a flight, sitting on my hotel bed and Skypeing the family via free Wifi, I prefer my tablet.

    I could go on and I hope your blog is not just about protecting the need for your good product.

  • Hi Glenn!
    Trust me, we know how useful and versatile tablets are — especially when traveling! The Office limitation is a big one for us, though, and there’s rumors of an official Microsoft Office iOS app coming soon. If it’s got the features we need, that takes care of one of the seven things tablets still can’t do. Maybe the others will happen too!

    We hope that the other articles on the site convince you that our blog is about far more than our products. Thanks for reading!

Didn't find your answer?
Ask a question to our community of experts from around the world and receive an answer in no time at all.

our products
See all products →

We develop products that help Repair, Optimize and Maintain your computer for you

Driver Reviver
Restore maximum performance and functionality to your PC's hardware.
Registry Reviver
Restore maximum efficiency and effectiveness to your PC's Windows Registry.
Security Reviver
Quickly and safely remove security threats, prevent them from reoccurring and keep your PC protected.
subscribe to our newsletter

Receive free tips and advices how
to repair, maintain and optimize your PC

Edit translation
Machine translation (Google):
Copy to editor
or Cancel